Connect with us

Reel News

American exceptionalism has become a hazard to our health

American Politics

American exceptionalism has become a hazard to our health

What explains why some countries have handled the covid-19 pandemic well and others have done poorly? It’s a complicated question, but if we look at the place that has arguably had the greatest success, the answer is failure.Taiwan gets the gold medal for its coronavirus strategy. It has close ties with mainland China, where the…

American exceptionalism has become a hazard to our health

What discusses why some nations have dealt with the covid-19 pandemic well and others have done poorly? It’s a complex concern, however if we look at the place that has perhaps had the best success, the answer is failure.

Taiwan gets the gold medal for its coronavirus technique. It has close ties with mainland China, where the disease originated, getting practically 3 million visitors from there in a common year. It is a largely inhabited land, and Taipei, the capital city, has crowded public transit. And yet, with a population of almost 24 million, Taiwan has had just 7 deaths New York state, with a smaller sized population, has actually had 33,000

Taiwan’s biggest property turns out to be its unsuccessful reaction to a pandemic in 2003, SARS, which taught it numerous crucial lessons. SARS was a respiratory infection, less contagious than covid-19 but more fatal SARS also came out of China, where authorities made a mess of the preliminary reaction and kept info from the outside world. The Taiwanese were caught unprepared and made several errors. In the aftermath, they absolutely overhauled their pandemic readiness procedures. They guaranteed they had adequate materials of devices on hand. They made strategies to act early, wisely and strongly.

Many Asia-Pacific countries have actually succeeded versus covid-19– South Korea, Vietnam, Singapore, New Zealand, Australia. All were hit by SARS or witnessed its financial damage, and they gained from the experience. The only non-Asian nation with a SARS outbreak was Canada, and it, too, changed its procedures after 2003 and took preventative measures Even China learned a good deal from its disastrous SARS response, and, regardless of early stumbles this time, Beijing has actually handled to squash covid-19 so completely that the disease has virtually disappeared from the country where it began. SARS does not describe the success of every nation that has actually dealt with covid-19 well, however it reveals an important element of the story.

Consider, on the other hand, countries that have actually handled covid-19 terribly. Anthropologist Martha Lincoln, composing in Nature, points out that several of these countries tend to believe of themselves as remarkable in some method. She keeps in mind that the United States, Britain, Brazil and Chile all have strong national stories that see themselves as different, distinct and much better than others. The United States is infamous for this attitude, however that is, after all, likewise the inspiration behind Britain’s desire to leave the European Union. Brazil, on the other hand, thinks it delights in good luck because “ God is Brazilian,” and Chile is smug about being the area’s economic superstar

Real Life. Real News. Real Voices

Help us tell more of the stories that matter

Become a founding member

That sense of being unique makes a country unlikely to adopt the standard attitude of any service when facing a difficulty– to search for best practices. Bill Gates just recently wrote that he has constantly approached analytical by beginning with two fundamental questions: “Who has handled this problem well? And what can we discover from them?” He suggests that we apply the same approach to the pandemic.

And yet the United States is extremely withdrawn in how other countries approach similar obstacles. Dozens of innovative nations have health-care systems that deliver better results at half the expense of America’s. A lot of have a fraction of our homicide rates. Lots of much poorer countries have much better infrastructure, which they develop at far lower cost. They make sure that cash does not control their elections. Not only do we not find out from them, we hardly trouble to look.

In an essay in Foreign Affairs, Jeremy Konyndyk argues that “American exceptionalism– the notion that the United States is unique amongst countries which the American method is invariably the very best– has blinded the nation’s leaders (and a lot of its residents) to possibly lifesaving lessons from other countries.” He estimates the distinguished U.S. historian Eric Foner, who as soon as discussed that American exceptionalism equates into “hubris and closed-mindedness, and. lack of knowledge about the rest of the world. Since the United States is so remarkable, there is no point in discovering other societies.” Konyndyk concludes: “That mindset is now costing American lives.” I fear he may be right.

Learn More:

Subscribe to the newsletter news

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe

To Top